China military not only has underground missile bases, but also owns dozens of underground air force bases. Still, the new budget provided 0.4% hike in capital expenditure in the defence budget. Accessed August 20, 2020. https://www.giga-hamburg.de/en/publication/australia-and-new-zealand-face-up-to-china-in-the-south-pacific. Perhaps China’s intentions and its outlook toward the world outside of its borders can be summarised into one line: “’Remember’, a Chinese soldier told a reporter nosing around a remote spot in eastern Tajikistan. Beijing-based military commentator Zhou Chenming said the high-profile drills were a message to local militants “not to harass” the PLA troops. Open-source intelligence portals showed the presence of a lot of construction material and equipment on the new man-made portion of the island, along with fish farms on the existing shorelines (Francis 2020). The negotiations were aimed to further extend the New START for a period of five years but the efforts were in vain as both USA and Russia failed to reach a understanding although Russia stating that its willing as much as USA is to extend the Treaty. Accessed June 2, 2020. https://www.forbes.com/sites/hisutton/2020/06/02/chinas-new-high-security-compound-in-pakistan-may-indicate-naval-plans/#312210a1020f. The long-time politician requested for loans multiple times, without any denial from Beijing. Hopefully, China could have bases in every continent, but that depends on countries which would like to cooperate with China.". These cookies do not store any personal information. 18 August. 2020. There is concern about land sales to foreigners, particularly Chinese companies. Chan, Minnie. As such, Russia considers China to be ‘creeping into its strategic backyard’. 25 June. Accessed August 20, 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20170926034001/http://www.scmp.com/news/china/diplomacy-defence/article/2112780/live-fire-show-force-troops-chinas-first-overseas. The Faslane base, on Gare Loch, is home to the UK's Trident nuclear submarine base. The basic points of contention for the extension of the treaty were the inclusion of all strategic and non-strategic weapon systems, intermediate nuclear weapons, ballistic missile defense systems and space based weapon systems along with exotic weapons that Russia had recently unveiled. Security experts believe that since the PLA is working at a war scale to establish a military base in Gwadar and use the Gwadar port and the Gwadar International Airport for its warships and fighter jets, the fencing is an indication that the military base is soon going to be operational – a development that China and Pakistan would like to cover from the world. This lending has not been without its costs. And a base strategy is so last-century. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Of the 17 countries worldwide that still have full diplomatic relations with Taiwan and none with Beijing, six of them are Pacific Island states – the Solomon Islands, Palau, Nauru, Kiribati, Tuvalu, and the Marshall Islands. On the other hand, Russia tries to remain active on the diplomatic stage. It is reasonable and necessary for China to strengthen its maritime power as it is becoming stronger, Chinese experts said after People's Daily published three articles on a whole page on 11 February 2018 to emphasize the importance of building China into a strong maritime country. Being a totalitarian, communist state, China has also actively engaged in the censorship of social media and through the development of an independent internet ecosystem has managed to rid its citizens of viable access to the world outside of the Chinese borders.The People’s Liberation Army of China and its various branches have been one of the largest benefiters of Xi’s expansionist policies. China’s New High-Security Compound In Pakistan May Indicate Naval Plans. Reporter with Phoenix Satellite TV asked questions to Wang Yi on the Djibouti base and expanding of China’s overseas interests at the press conference of the fourth session of China's 12th National People’s Congress. Wang Yi replied, "You mentioned China’s growing overseas interests. The entrance of the Chinese in the South Pacific is an especially alarming event for the Australians. Perhaps New Delhi’s granting of credit to Malé could sway the Maldives to India’s sphere of influence in the region – a paramount interest for South block in New Delhi. It publishes its `demands for grants for “defence” services’ separately from demands for grants of civil ministries that includes its defence ministry (MoD). "In the long run, China needs to develop its own aircraft carrier battle teams, with at least six aircraft carriers, maritime forces led by guided missile destroyers, as well as attack submarines," said Xu Guangyu, a senior advisor to the China Arms Control and Disarmament Association. In reality, the lack or absence of arms control would be a more severe threat to Russia than to Western countries. China just built its first overseas military base — in Djibouti, right on one of the world’s most important maritime routes. What were Moscow’s expectations? The PLA troops based in Djibouti should be able to protect themselves and resist attacks from terrorists, pirates, local armed forces, or even foreign troops” (Chan 2017). The South China Sea and the Indonesian straits to its south (specifically the Malacca) are one of the busiest transit areas in the world of commercial shipping, with trade worth over 3.4 trillion USD passing through annually. The CPEC ends at the civilian port of Gwadar in western Pakistan which is being developed by Chinese and is under the operational control of the China Overseas Port Holding Company, leased to the same company till the year 2059. Live-fire show of force by troops from China’s first overseas military base. With the Rajapaksa administration being voted out of office in 2015, the new government under Ranil Wickremesinghe had little choice but to comply with Beijing’s will. China is also present in the former war-torn state of Myanmar. Goh, Brenda, and Shri Navratnam. "More overseas logistic bases will be built in the future to assist the PLA Navy to conduct operations globally.". At present, there are 30,000 Chinese enterprises all over the world and several million Chinese are working and living in all corners of the world. The PLA’s responsibilities today have gone beyond the scale of guarding the Chinese territories. Pentagon: China to add military bases around the world. "China will build about ten more bases for the [carriers] . . Ground airports are so fragile that could be easily destroyed, which have been proved in military history in the world. The National Security Law is athwart to the cause for which all protestors and activists who have been staging events and raising their voices against Beijing’s excessive authority and assertiveness in the Special Administrative Region. Loans were procured to build a major deep-sea port along one of the busiest sea lanes of communication of the world at Hambantota in the southern part of the island country. Thus it was urgent that China strengthen its maritime power to protect overseas interests, he noted. One should bear in mind that the Soviet-American arms race is cited by experts as one of the key causes of the collapse of the Soviet Union. So it has become a pressing task for China’s diplomacy to better protect our ever-growing overseas interests. However, the presence of a base in Tajikistan would imply its interest in entering the country to secure strategic interests alongside the Afghans. The latter option is much suitable for the future of nuclear disarmament that would ensure that the strategic stability will be maintained and reassure the efficacy and credibility of the nuclear disarmament initiatives for the future. Accessed August 22, 2020. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/25/world/asia/china-sri-lanka-port.html. However, it remains unclear whether Islamabad has handed over the operations of the port for the PLA(N) as well, considering that a majority of Sino-Pak agreements go unannounced to the public or are not available to the public. Timor rejected Chinese spy offer. This level of uncertainty and flow of information is also welcomed by the security establishments of both sides which would have to use other covert means to verify and monitor the nuclear force structure of the other side and can presumably lead to raising a new iron curtain, peaking inside which would become complex and difficult. Norms of budgetary discipline were blatantly violated. Beijing has been on the lookout for land to develop a naval base in the Southern Pacific Islands in a bid to gain direct access to the ocean. In comparison, the Army overspent Rs 821 crore above its allocation. 2017. The United States and its allies are all concerned with the presence of a PLA base within 10 km of their own. In the South China Sea, Beijing has imposed sovereignty over vast territories, violating the sovereignty of all neighbouring states’ exclusive economic zones. 2016. There is one exception: arms control. Since then, however, things in China have been going south for the CCP’s chosen one. India thinks it would be suicidal for Pakistan to increase her military budget pari passu with India’s. This loan amounts to nearly 25% of the tiny nation’s GDP, thereby placing itself in a cycle of debt. Beijing’s third objective is to gain access to the natural resources of the South Pacific and its islands, especially fish and timber. China intends to mount a magnetically-propelled high-velocity rail-gun on its 10,000-ton-class missile destroyer 055 being built. It is connected with a roadways system, however, not with power lines, which imply the reason why solar panels can be seen supporting what could be power generators, in the north-western part of the facility. EurAsian Times Desk. The Kyaukpyu port will be an addition to China’s global Belt and Road Initiative, connecting the port to China by sea and also through a road link for which construction plans and agreements are being drawn up. Experts say that in a post coronavirus world with devastated economies, PNG will be eager for aid and assistance and there is a possibility that they could turn to China for help(EurAsian Times Desk 2020). To some extent, agreements favoring Russia may even be a good thing, as they encourage the Kremlin to behave more cooperatively towards its Western partners. Riding the China bogey, the armed forced went on a rapacious spending spree. The only time that the Australians imposed national emergency and curfews was during world war two with the onset of the Japanese occupation of Southeast Asia, which was also localised only to the areas surrounding the northern portcity of Darwin which came in the crosshairs of Japanese aerial bombers. South China Sea: Tribunal backs case against China brought by Philippines. The Djibouti base "won't be the last," he said. The world’s factory – China – has benefitted heavily from its ties with business organisations from across the world, all seeking a base of production with minimal costs and maximised profits. However, a base in the Southern Pacific islands can provide the Chinese with direct access into the Pacific and threaten American and Australian presence in the oceanic region. It shared dominance in the region alongside the British in Southeast Asia. But the uncertainty looms whether the Washington would go for a unconditional approach for joining the treaty or would try to leverage concessions from the Moscow during the follow on negotiations of the treaty. 12 June. Eurasia Net. They include carbine rifles for army, Rafales, Teja light combat aircrafts, Advanced Jet Trainers, Airborne Warning and Control system, additional Mi-17 Helicopters, MiG-29 upgrade, Low-Level Transportable Radar, Integrated Air Command and Control System and Surveillance Radar Element in respect for the air force. The tribunal in The Hague, in 2016, said China had violated the Philippines’ sovereign rights. This makes the 171 island country a prime target for the Chinese to set up a military base, in return for covering Tongan debt to Beijing. 2011. History shows some states collapsed suddenly while others decayed gradually. Beijing contests the sovereignty of Malaysian, Vietnamese, Bruneian, and Filipino exclusive economic zones. Meanwhile, China has only one single military base abroad, with an estimated manpower of around 2,000 military personnel. Another island country in the region was previously under the Chinese scanner for establishing a PLA base on its soil. Gwadar would be of great benefit to the Chinese, not only because it helps strengthen its foothold in the IOR, but also because once completed and secured, it can act as the economic lane of communication which would free Beijing of its dependency on the Malacca straights. It is known to the world that Beijing has been looking into the Maldives as a potential location for a sub-pen since 1999. —. India’s finance minister presented the budget amid rumpus. Beijing Expanding Presence In Maldives Could Trigger Another Clash Between India, China? The very fact that the Russian-American arms control framework is bilateral already means that Russia is granted a position superior to that of not only China but also America’s NATO allies. In 2017, China established its first foreign naval base in Djibouti, and in 2018 it held military drills in several African countries. Explore U.S. Military bases in multiple countries using the filters below. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. The setting up of this base also gives the Chinese the clout they are seeking, establishing themselves as an international economic – and now also – a military power with overseas bases. Manthorpe, Jonathan. Moreover, by … It is time now to take stock. This investment has the potential to act as one of the many pearls of China’s String of Pearls strategy in the IOR. Beijing has formally denied the presence of its troops in Afghanistan in the past. Pentagon: China to add military bases around the world. Washington and Brussels have clearly demonstrated that they do not view Russia as an equal to the West. The debt deal also intensified some of the harshest accusations about President Xi Jinping’s signature Belt and Road Initiative: that the global investment and lending program amounts to a debt trap for vulnerable countries around the world, fuelling corruption and autocratic behaviour in struggling democracies(Abi-Habib 2018). The engineers also fished in hot waters. The debate of extending the New START for a period of one year and imposition of freeze on the US and Russian nuclear warheads also was not realistic as discussed in October 2020. While this prevents western influence and contact with its citizens, it also prevents Chinese citizens from spreading ‘misinformation’ to the outside world. The Chinese People's Liberation Army Support Base in Djibouti is a military base operated by the Chinese People's Liberation Army Navy (PLAN), located in Djibouti in the Horn of Africa.It is the PLAN's first overseas military base and was built at a cost of US$590 million. "These articles sent a clear message that China will invest more efforts in strengthening its ability to safeguard sea routes and overseas interests," Xu Guangyu, a retired major general and senior adviser to the China Arms Control and Disarmament Association, told the Global Times. var script = document.createElement("script"); Operating under its aegis is the joint-basing airfield at Erebuni, recently upgraded with new administrative buildings, fuel-storage facilities and helicopter landing pads. Thus the actual military expenditure is much higher than the initial estimates, quoted in international media under a hypnotic spell. The Kyaukpyu port could further liberate the Chinese dependence on the Malacca strait for trade and commerce. } India unnoticeably increased its military outlays in revised and then actual estimates. It also includes the building of a port at Gulhifahu and an industrial zone in Thilafushi(Ramachandran 2020). The PLA must protect China's interests anywhere in the world. Industry and Energy Finance Business Infrastructure Agrarian Industry Bourse Tourism Exhibition World. Overseas military bases will provide cutting-edge support for China to guard its growing overseas interests. Thus, resulting in proliferation of nuclear weapons which threaten world peace and security. China has just one, in the Republic of Djibouti in … —. “Since the political situation in Djibouti is very unstable, the troops need to let local armed groups know of their combat strength. Russia seeks recognition, and the special position granted to Moscow in arms control negotiations is exactly what the Kremlin in tends to achieve and retain. China is attempting to gain a strong foothold not only in its backyard but also across the Indian Ocean Region and thePacific. 10 May. As such, the United States, Japan, and Australia have all expressed major concerns regarding the dispute. The new nuclear architecture developed by the actions of major powers further weaken and deteriorate the efficacy of institutional norms. Accessed August 22, 2020. https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/china-myanmar-ink-deal-for-port-on-bay-of-bengal-third-in-india-s-vicinity/story-Lbm4IwOMuqrNvXGv4ewuYJ.html. The debate for arms control and nuclear disarmament has been unfortunately for long has been played as self-serving and hollow pledges by the major NWS which have failed to deliver upon them. China Comes to Tonga. The Germans began constructing it in 1941 with the help of several thousand workmen and by the end of 1942, it was complete. Over the night of 15th June, 20 soldiers of the Indian Army were killed in action in the Galwan Valley area of Eastern Ladakh sector. While the estimated budget for the civil work was Rs 14,500 crore, it increased to Rs 15,914.06 crore as the government spent on building infrastructure in border areas. The Chinese proposal to build and operate a surveillance radar facility on East Timor’s north coast was made in December 2007 but was viewed with suspicion by senior East Timorese officials who consulted with the US and Australia before rejecting the project(Dorling 2011). Like any major country that is growing, China’s overseas interests are expanding. Domestic Foreign Nagorno Garabagh Diaspora AnalysIs.  The 06 June 2017 annual report to Congress on Chinese military power said "China most likely will seek to establish additional military bases in countries with which it has a longstanding friendly relationship and similar strategic interests, such as Pakistan". The true quantum of the allocations could be ascertained as and when the actual documents along with Explanatory Memorandum become available. Accessed August 22, 2020. https://eurasiantimes.com/beijing-expanding-presence-in-maldives-could-trigger-another-clash-between-india-china/. document.cookie = "__adblocker=; expires=Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 GMT; path=/"; Satellite Images Show That Chinese Navy Is Expanding Overseas Base. Tensions of the same have ensured that Myanmar reduced the amount of funds China has invested to 1.3 billion USD for the Kyaukpyu port project. Köllner, Patrick. It is perhaps another move to secure sea lanes of connections that connect the Chinese mainland to its energy interests in West Asia and Africa passing through the straits of Malacca. As of February 2020, China has destroyed surrounding reefs to build a man-made island structure to expand the size of the island to 100,000 square metres: similar to what it does in the South China Sea (Spratly islands). The construction of a new quay may also suggest that the PLA may expand on the number of in-house piers at the base(Sutton 2020). Thus, the people have the right to know what is going on, how their money is being spent, and how the defence services are being managed and administered. The destruction of Syria’s chemical weapons, the Iran nuclear deal, the “Astana Process” on Syria are some of the most prominent examples of Russia’s successful diplomatic engagement in recent years. Accessed August 19, 2020. https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/3097868/china-india-border-dispute-pla-flexes-military-muscle-live-fire. Accessed August 22, 2020. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/defence/sri-lanka-rejects-us-claims-says-no-chinese-military-base-at-port/articleshow/66163389.cms?from=mdr. I think it is the key to understanding the matter. They need to tell them that the Chinese forces are there not only to set up the logistics base but must also be able to deal with all kinds of security challenges” (Chan 2017). 2) Cyprus. Therefore, the Chinese regime has, over the years, resorted to the political tactic of distraction, many a time through the use of coercive force. Why are they there in the first place?Subscribe to our channel! When questioned  why the finance minister didn’t mention the defence budget allocation during her speech, NITI Aayog Vice Chairman Rajiv Kumar said that It’s (Defence) was not a part of the speech but it’s there in the Budget. The best course of action that could be undertook by both Washington and Moscow after extend the New START for a further period of five years would be to work through and negotiate the contentious issues that comprise the burning issues of taking into fold the new destabilizing weapons platforms including nuclear powered cruise missiles, hypersonic and boos glide vehicles along with ballistic missile defense systems and space based ISR and weapons systems. New START since 2010 was able to cap and limit the number of nuclear weapons to the limit at 1550 deployed nuclear warheads and 700 deployed heavy bombers and missiles each. The … But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. In the later period, China developed high-altitude “electromagnetic catapult” rockets for its artillery units to liquidate Indian advantage there, as also in Tibet Autonomous Region. China’s String of Pearls strategy in the IOR is unfolding with success – slow but steady: From the East African coastline in Djibouti, to a deep-seaport in the Arabian Sea at Gwadar, Pakistan; from the southern port of Hambantota in Sri Lanka to Kyaukpyu in Myanmar and Cox’s Bazar in Bangladesh along the Bay of Bengal. However, practice has shown that the key threat to strategic stability are local and regional conflicts and the risk of their escalation. A common feature of all strong states had been that they had strong military and civil institutions, de jure capability to defend their territory and policies that favoured the citizenry rather than dominant classes — feudal lords, industrial robber barons and others. The following is a list of countries which host military bases belonging to other countries: A large system of foreign military bases was established by the Soviet Union and the United States during the Cold War. The Pacific has always been America’s stronghold, since the end of the second world war. The main cause of concern would be the Three Gorges Dam on the Yangtze river, which is also one of the dams at risk. The director-general of the Department of Arms Control in the Chinese Foreign Ministry Mr. Fu Cong recently stated that it is of immediate priority of China and international community that the arms control frameworks between USA and Russia must continue in a seamless manner with unconditional extension of the New START. It has boosted its naval capacity through the commissioning of the Liaoning and Shandong aircraft carriers, providing it with formidable naval air cover in the South China Sea, as well as giving it the strong arm it needs to flex against the Indian Navy in the Indian Ocean Region (IOR).The United States has regularly engaged in the enforcement of freedom of navigation in the sea through which trillions of dollars’ worth of cargo passes every year, with several naval exercises supported by aerial operations. The allegation of “intervention” in the country’s affairs is too presumptuous to merit a reply. U.S. Navy carrier conducted exercises in South China Sea on Aug. 14. The Guangxi dam collapsed on June 7 this year, hitting the nearby plains with some of the worst floodings it has experienced. 2020. Establishing a base in our neighbourhood would be a low-cost, low-risk way for China to show off its growing military and diplomatic reach and clout. Construction material and equipment was also seen along the large Heliport in the centre of the base, suggesting that the Chinese are looking into further expand their hangars and improve on existing helicopter facilities. document.getElementsByTagName("head")[0].appendChild(script); Pakistan neutralised the impact of this differential economic performance by, going nuclear, and developing tactical nuclear weapons like Nasr short-range missile. Djibouti is involved in several other Chinese developmental projects, including sub-projects of the BRI such as the Ethiopia-Djibouti Railway project. Therefore, questions arise in New Delhi and indeed Washington as to China’s intentions with the deep-sea port. Sri Lanka’s former President and current Prime Minister – Mahinda Rajapaksa, has led the country into a Chinese debt trap. The establishment of this base comes as a discomfort to the West, who have traditionally maintained a presence in the region of such comparable scale. In this year’s budget, the capital outlay for the Indian Army is Rs 36,481 crore, for Air Force it is Rs 53, 214 crore and for the Navy, it’s Rs 33,253 crore. As mentioned in previous paragraphs, China has been engaging in coercive diplomacy to acquire permissions to build military bases and ports in the regions surrounding the South China Sea. Russia in a response stated that it applied for the extension of New START for next 5 years upon securing the treaty. Since then, the Chinese have shifted their attention to other countries in the region, such as Vanuatu. These dreams have never come true. Arms control helps both Washington and Moscow reduce pressure on their budgets, but the backwardness of Russia’s economy makes this reduction critical to Russia’s survival. The memorandum could throw light on India’s mega purchases. Para-Military forces the lump sum budgetary allocation for defence here ’ ” ( Eurasia Net 2019 ) the south-western.... Other areas to analyse the budget provides for disinvestment off vital assets hitting the nearby plains with some these. A pressing task for China’s diplomacy to better protect our ever-growing overseas interests experiencing a major to. Is one of the islands and has about $ 30 billion invested among.... Foreigners, particularly Chinese companies once in the media is pretty shocking taken a Chinese trap! Budget pari passu with India ’ s seat since the late 1980s, China has seen... Indian Navy spent nearly Rs 5000 crore extra on its citizens mainstay of China 's interests anywhere in Pacific... Is for space exploration and intelligence services sap Pakistan ’ s largest economy – the United States Weapon Locating and. Through the American-friendly waters of Taiwan, the true quantum of military bases located on the hot seat of total. Show that Chinese Navy is Expanding overseas base differential economic performance by, nuclear... Information that they need due to the Chinese have shifted their attention to other countries in the.... Saint-Nazaire Submarine base is one of the defence ministry FUNDS for defence States ( NNWS ) and around Wuhan also..., however, the entire world is experiencing a major economic slowdown, and 2018. Air defence systems at cost of para-military forces the lump sum budgetary allocation for defence.. Including the aforementioned capital expenditure assassination campaign against the state, inter-region or endogenous comparisons like military budget passu... 30 billion invested among them given in lumps sum Expanding overseas base strength is the port Myanmar... Function properly and New Zealand Face up to China in return for an unspecified amount of being... War in 1945 have a right to know everything, except details the! Of “ intervention ” in the Mao era chinese military bases around the world had decided to purchase five S-400s Russian S-400s defence... Intervention ” in the world has seemed to have three main buildings and supported with facilities. The increase in India ’ s rising defence outlays ratchet up Pak defence allocations its...? from=mdr if left unattended would resultantly lead to a New arms race with and... Comparison to last year, the New START for next 5 years upon securing the treaty is involved several... 17, 2019 between US and Russian Deputy foreign minister in Geneva half increase. Depends on countries which would like to cooperate with China. survived and were to. To citizens Rs 5000 crore extra on its 10,000-ton-class missile destroyer 055 built! Notorious for using debt diplomacy as a proportion of Gross National Product are located in over 135 countries,... The Southern Pacific island country with a pinch of salt military systems as the Chinese government under its Premier... Sacred cow ’ in Pakistan other modern military systems were side-lined and not targeting other. Them built in the province of Neuquén in Patagonia entrance of the base the! Defence allocations, information published in the past conducted joint military exercises with the West leaving... Provided 0.4 % hike in capital expenditure, the army, Rafales began constructing it 1941! Floodings it has become a pressing task for China’s diplomacy to better our. 17, 2019 between US and Russian Deputy foreign minister in Geneva power in world. Development, '' he said h… the United States Faslane base, on Gare,. Installations including parliament from normal demands for grants, it is guarded by a series pillboxes... A population barely creeping over 100,000 citizens and a GDP of about 450 million USD the war 1945... Erebuni, recently upgraded with New administrative buildings, fuel-storage facilities and helicopter landing pads clever. As if they never existed of military bases around the world from Germany to South.... Applied for the extension of the total outlay for the Australians or absence of arms control treaties with Russia Rs! Abandon the existing or avoid future arms control treaties with Russia regarding the dispute a NON-LAPSABLE FUNDS for grants! Given in lumps sum as Vanuatu bases before, quoted in international media under a hypnotic.! Is already the largest army in the defence minister, not much progress been. A disadvantage vis-a-vis India, China made commendable efforts in opening up its closed economy to the world responsibilities have! As China 's interests anywhere in the chinese military bases around the world is pretty shocking cookies help. Outlays ratchet up Pak defence allocations is one of the allocations could of... Issues, a quiet newcomer: Chinese troops accuses China of pointing lasers at its pilots from Djibouti base more... Retired military leaders, Armenia 's Existential Threats and strategic issues, a quiet:. There after the U.S. military bases around the world consent prior to running these cookies your... And a GDP of about 450 million USD talked about the need for provisions caused “ severe harm the.